Persona
Trans-parenting
Persona
Pleasure games
Introduction
This project began in Vienna in 2012. While taking the subway, I was pleased to notice the sign requesting that passengers give up their seats for those who need them. My attention was attracted not only by the range of colors, but especially by the various iconographies representing gender, age, or a specific situation like someone holding a child in their arms. The first thing that came to mind was that in Mexico we are still far away from having equitable images in public transport. Also in Vienna, while going through a mall and walking through a toy store I couldn’t resist taking a look at the Playmobil products – these toys being part of my childhood. I hadn’t seen in Mexico the sets that I saw in Vienna that day, maybe because it had been years that I hadn’t stopped at a toy store, or maybe because those particular sets did not make it to the Mexican market. To be honest, I couldn’t decide which of those affirmations is true since I didn’t investigate it back in Mexico, and I didn’t even think about it again until a couple of years later. What surprised me then was the perfectly defined roles in the sets. In the ones containing female Playmobil, we could find housewives performing different domestic tasks: one was ironing, the other was watching after the kids. There were no female spies or pirates, nor were there men doing domestic tasks. I saw in this a deep contrast with the subway signage.
Around the end of 2016, I continued this project and decided to analyze the Playmobil line under the premise that gender is a performative* act that we keep on reinforcing since our childhood. One way of reinforcing these behaviors and gender roles is through play and through objects that determine what is appropriate for a man or a woman to do.
My analysis is very specific: I focused on the Playmobil line of 2016. It just takes to go to a toy store and observe the color palettes, the objects, the characters and actions that the brands propose through their toy products to define the male or female gender/ From a brief visit to a toy store and a glance at the color palettes, the objects, the characters and their actions, one is immediately aware of the brands’ implicit definition of male and female gender roles.
I want to mention that in the 2016 line I didn’t find the sets that I saw in Vienna in 2012, and there were men performing domestic tasks, however I also found data to support Butler’s theory.
- Judith Butler, Gender trouble: feminism and the subversion of identity
Distribution among genders
Playmobil 2016 has approximately 545 figures representing human beings categorized as follows:
Distribution among skin colours from 305 men
Distribution among skin colours from 150 women
Distribution among skin colours from 34 male kids
Distribution among skin colours from 40 female kids
Distribution among skin colours from 16 babies
Methodology
I downloaded the entire catalogue from the Playmobil website, as well as the images of all the sets to see specific details.
The margin of error in the total is +/- 2 figures since some figures are repeated in various categories of the catalogue.
The study’s limit is the 2016 Playmobil toy line, excepting Playmobil 1.2.3, meant for 1 to 3-year-old kids.
Categories
The toy line is divided into the following categories:
City Action, City Life, Country, Dollhouse, Family Fun, History, Others, Princess, Sports & Action, Super 4, Wild Life.
City Action has the following subcategories:
Firefighters, Cargo Transporter, Construction, Coast guard, City Cleaner, Police, Space
City Life has the following subcategories:
Mall, Fashion Boutique, Nursery, Children’s Hospital, Modern Luxurious Mansion, Zoo.
Family Fun has the following subcategories:
Camping, Amusement Park, Water Zoo
History has the following subcategories:
Knights, Pirates, Western
Sports and Action has the following subcategories:
Outdoor, Football, Ice hockey, Motorcycle
The other main categories don’t have subcategories.
Iconographic genders
To understand the study, it’s important to determine how to define gender on a symbolic level in the Playmobil toy line.
Women
Make-up / Lips with lipstick / Big eyelashes / Badges (XXX)
Breasts / The toys don’t show any genitals but there is a hint of mammary glands
Hair / There isn’t any woman with short hair
Men
Face hair / Beard / Moustache
There is only one man with long hair in the categories representing our present time
City Life / Fashion Boutique / 6148 catwalks
Professions - Activities
Women
Firefighter
Astronaut
Engineer
Business Woman
Family woman
Coastguard
Rescuer
Shipwreck Survivor
Veterinarian
Salesperson in a mall
Client in a mall
Florist
Hatmaker
Model
Fashion show juror (or judge)
Celebrity
Photograph
Bride (as in Bride/Groom)
Children Caretaker
Mother
Nurse
Doctor
X ray technician
Swimmer
Horseback rider
Tourist
Cashier
Helicopter Pilot
Injured person
Farmer
Zoo caretaker
Surfer
Lifesaver
Princess
Queen
Pirate*
Fairy
Scientist
Adventurer
Gatherer
Prize winner
Victorian woman
Angel
Indian princess
Gymnast
Fitness teacher
Multimedia woman
Cockatoo caretaker
Men
Firefighter
Astronaut
Engineer
Plane pilot
Businessman
Family man
Vehicle operator
Coastguard
Rescuer
Shipwreck Survivor
Construction worker
Heavy machine operator
Crane operator
Truck driver
Construction supervisor
Laborer
Riot policeman
Helicopter Pilot
Delinquent
Mechanic
Porsche owner
Ice cream vendor
Fast food vendor
Fashion show jury
Photographer
Traffic guard
Doctor
X ray technician
Dentist
Father
Swimmer
Knight
King
Soldier
Pirate
Sailor
Bandit
Sheriff
Native American
Horseback rider
Trainer
Tourist
Injured person
Farmer
Zoo caretaker
Veterinary
groom
Surfer
Life saver
Motorcyclist
Football player
Ice hockey player
Spy
Scientist
Adventurer
Explorer
Fisherman
Submariner
Clown
Samurai
Viking
Magician
Cowboy
Woodcutter
San Martin
Santa Claus
Llama man
Wolf man
Buccaneer
Conclusion
At what age in our childhood are we taught to be male or female?
Gender is taught at home and in one’s social environment. The mass communication media reinforce it: internet, including social networks and youtube, television, and radio.
If gender is performative, it is from the ludic aspect that we reinforce gender norms using objects, colors and concepts we associate with femininity and masculinity.
“One is a woman since she operates as a woman in the dominant heterosexual structure.” (Preface page 12 Judith Butler: Gender trouble: feminism and the subversion of identity)
Also of note in the Playmobil 2016 catalogue are the gender roles; men are predisposed to violent behaviors - or associated with objects to exercise violence - while women are assigned passive roles: princess, brides, fairies, mothers, teachers, veterinarians, and doctors. The women’s objects include mirrors, canes, cars, houses, mansions, magic creatures while the men have missile trucks or any kind of weapon depending on the toy line. Men are bold, they face danger, they sometimes rob or defend treasures.
The Playmobil line gives us a glimpse of reality. We cannot say that Hans Beck had planned the sets in 1974 intending to reinforce the heteropatriarchy; however, we are now in 2017 and we can’t consider this study without observing the differences, roles, and gender performativity within the sets. The toy industry is part of the big ideological machinery that normalizes behaviors and roles, reflected in Mexican society by problems ranging from micromachismo to gender-based violence.
The standardization of violence in the game
We live in a society where we celebrate violence and gratify the dominant traditional masculinity, according to a study conducted by the Spanish National Center for Innovation and Education Investigation (CNIIE).
This study proposes a new model of an alternative to the traditional models of masculinity.
The New Alternative Masculinity has three fundamental characteristics: confidence in oneself, courage to confront negative behaviors of the Dominant Traditional Masculinity (sexism, racism, etc.), and the explicit rejection of double standards. This model of masculinity represents a real alternative to the traditional models of masculinity because it combines ethical language and the language of desire, in order to build equitable relationships and actively fight gender violence.
Preventive socialization of gender violence
It is important to observe that behaviors are being reinforced through play and/or objects so that we may change this ideological inertia and build a new value system based on fair relationships. Thinking about how we construct gender based on the ludic aspect of our childhood as well as avoiding the promotion of inequitable gender dynamics can be a prevention method against gender violence at all age.
Although the toy industry, the advertising industry, and in general the mass communication media are not evolving at the same pace, it is our responsibility to question, seek information, and educate our children, grandchildren, students, friends etc. on gender equality.